| Jeremiah Howard, Martes Lewis (2019) |
| Justen Ramsey (2018) |
| James Kirklen (2016) |
| Anthony Tucker (2015) |
| Zac Wells (Coach), Bryant Isabell, Ryan Neal, Tom Scolaro (2013) |
| Ryan Neal, Aaron Dye, Jake Raspopovich (2012) |
| Kourtney Berry, Jake Raspopovich (2011) |
| Matthew Neal, Denzel Pierce (2010) |
| James Travis, Sanchez Tate (2009) |
| Keith Dockery, Aaron Kaczmarski (2008) |
| Dionte Day, Demario Richardson, Ryan Stokes, Jarret Rucker (2007) |
| Drew Dawson (2006) |
| James Aldridge, Brandon Jordan, Dexter Larimore, Rayshon Richardson (2005) |
| James Aldridge, Michael Neal, Bart Woodward (2004) |
| Brandon Mosely (2003) |
| Timidayo McCarthy (2002) |
| Riley Larimore (2001) |
| Bruce Blue (2000) |
| Adam Fedak, Antwoine Gaines, Vincent Magee (1999) |
| Eugene Wilson, Mike Megyesi (1998) |
| Ryan Francis, Aaron Steele (1997) |
| Joe Giordano, Montell Pace (1996) |
| Matt Sieker (1995) |
| Warren Connor, Kevin Erny (1994) |
| Dave Joseforsky, Jamel Williams, Zac Wells (1992) |
| Donnie Bankhead, Joe Clark (1991) |
| Doug Downs (1990) |
| Mike Parker (1988) |
| Todd Gill (1987) |
| Mike Mackey, Brian Storey (1986) |
| Chris Cochran, Tim O'Shea (1985) |
| John Ogiego (1982) |
| Scott Plesha (1981) |
| Greg Mackey (1980) |
| Max Gill, Tom Jelesky (1978) |
| Mike Chelovich, Larry Tharp, Tim Seneff (1977) |
| Kelly Keough, Randy Shuman, Tom Szmagaj (1976) |
| Tom Vandenburgh (1975) |
| Ken Dike, Bob Uremovich (1973) |
| Kirk Kuzmiz, Walt Prochino (1971) |
| George Uremovich (1969) |
| Bill Schmidt (1965) |
| Al Schmidt (1964) |
| Pete Uremovich (1962) |
| Dan Molchan (1949) |
